If your home insurance policy is up for renewal – you should always do a comparison with quotes from other insurers before you renew with your current insurer – you could save yourself quite a bit of money.
The National Consumer Agency did a small comparison survey of home insurance premiums in August 2013. They compared insurance quotes from 8 different insurers on 6 different properties.
Overall – Zurich Insurance came out the best with the lowest quote in half of the examples . Aviva ,FBD and Axa provided the lowest quote in 1 case each.
AIG seemed to be the insurer with the highest prices – they came out as the most expensive in two thirds of the quotes. Aviva had the highest quote in 1 of the examples and RSA were the dearest in the remaining one. AIG also came out as the most expensive in a similar 2012 comparison.
The level of variation in the price of insurance was surprising. In one example for contents insurance the quote from AIG was over 4 times higher then the lowest quote from FBD (€389 compared to €88) .
On combined buildings and contents insurance there was one example of a quote from AIG being 3 times more than the cheapest one from Zurich (€545 v €184) .
The comparison mainly used direct insurers – but sometimes a broker might be able to get a better deal for you.
See here for a 2012 House Insurance Comparison
Ref: Consumer Help